YOUNGSTOWN, Ohio – A new exhibition will tell the story of Isaly’s, the chain of deli and ice cream shops that was once prevalent throughout the region.
“Welcome to Isaly’s: A Youngstown Story” will open Friday, Aug. 22, at the Arms Family Museum, 648 Wick Ave. A closing date has not yet been announced.
The exhibition will feature numerous Isaly’s artifacts and photos, displayed in a retro diner-like setting.
Arms Family Museum is open from noon to 4 p.m. Tuesdays-Sundays. Admission also includes a visit to Tyler History Center, downtown.
Isaly’s Dairy Co. was started in Mansfield in 1899 and established a foothold in Youngstown in 1918, with its main plant at 1033 Mahoning Ave.
The company quickly found success among local residents with its dairy products, luncheon meats and ice cream treats.
In 1939, the Mahoning Avenue plant underwent an art deco remodel with a 36,250-square-foot addition for manufacturing, storage and office space. At this time, about 260 people were employed there.
The plant’s five-story glass block tower, designed by renowned architect Charles F. Owsley, became a landmark of Youngstown.
By 1951, Isaly’s had established nearly 150 retail stores in the Youngstown area. However, the company’s presence would not last much longer. Beginning in the 1960s, Isaly’s retail stores began to slowly disappear as consumer preferences changed.
In 1969, Isaly’s moved ice cream production to Pittsburgh. In 1970, milk processing and pasteurizing ceased at the Mahoning Avenue plant, which then closed.
The building was purchased in 1977 by U-Haul.
Isaly’s may no longer exist in the area, but the memories of those who experienced it continue.
Pictured at top: A sign from a former Isaly’s store is part of the exhibition at the Arms Family Museum.